Guest contributor: Bruce Roberts, Chief Executive Officer of Carofin*
Before making an alternative investment, Investors should analyze and verify information provided to them by the Issuer. Typically, an Investor will be presented with the Offering Documents, such as a Private Placement Memorandum or other Summary Offering Material (SOM). But due diligence involves diving more deeply into Offering materials. Investors should understand all areas of the business — and the backgrounds of the key individuals managing the business – before proceeding.
Defining Due Diligence
Due diligence regarding investments in private companies means investigating all aspects of the business and the Security being offered. This includes independently evaluating whether the statements in the Offering Documents are complete, consistent and accurate, with no material facts omitted. It takes more work by the Investor…but it’s worth it!
Why So Important?
In short, the Securities Act of 1933 has fraud provisions which require the Issuer and its representatives to disclose all material facts accurately and fully.
If Issuers are not willing (or not able) to discuss their business in greater detail than is provided in the Offering Documents, even when under the protection of a Non-Disclosure Agreement (NDA) between the Issuer and the Investor, they should be treated with great caution.
The information that has been collected during the due diligence process (i.e. before the investment is made available to Investors) should also be readily available to potential Investors. With the internet, this is relatively easy to do. This information often is provided to prospective Investors via a web-based portal, enabling them to make more informed decisions.
Do You Really Know the Issuers?
The SEC publishes a questionnaire under Rule 506 section of Regulation D (Reg D) called Rule 506 Disqualification Questionnaire (also informally called the “Bad Actor Questionnaire”) which key persons are required to complete.
A background search for the Issuer’s key persons (as defined in the Bad Actor Questionnaire) should include:
1. Searches regarding bankruptcies, outstanding Liens and judgements, and criminal background history
2. Searches pertaining to each person’s related businesses for bankruptcies and outstanding Liens and judgments
3. An internet search for negative news for each key person
4. Litigation searches for each key person
5. A search of Office of Foreign Assets Control’s (OFAC) sanctions lists for each person and entity.
What Other Information Should You Have about the Issuing Company?
Areas for analysis include company overview (product/service opportunity), financing overview, market overview (customers/competition), management, Investors, employees and related parties, financial information, corporate documents of the company and subsidiaries, previous financings and capital structure, material contracts and agreements, litigation, property/intellectual property, taxation, insurance and liability, acquisition, partnership or joint venture agreements, governmental regulations and filings, and operations.
While the emphasis during a due diligence analysis will naturally be more heavily weighted to the specifics of the potential investment, areas that may originally seem less significant can ultimately have a significantly detrimental impact on an investment if they are not addressed properly.
To help an Investor learn about specifics within each of the categories mentioned above, please read on.
Company Overview (Product/Service Opportunity)
When analyzing a company, review its business plan to understand its products or services and why it stands out from its competitors. Understand each product or service, how the Company plans to bring each to market, and what is the production process or service offering platform. What are its production challenges, and to what degree has the market accepted its products/services? Review marketing studies, consulting studies or reports and conduct background searches.
An Investor should ask why the Company is raising capital now. What is driving the timing behind the raise? How does Management plan to use the funds? What is the projected Capitalization of the Company before and after the funds have been raised?
If the Company can project exit strategies, who might be the potential buyers, or might an initial public offering be a viable strategy? What return should you expect on this investment and over what period?
Are there relevant articles or marketing studies relating to the Company or the industry? Is there information supporting the aggregate market size? What are the demand drivers? Can the Issuer provide a list of near-term customers and the top 20 customers that includes sales concentration and contract terms?
While the Investor may not have direct access to this information, try to determine, among other things, what is the top customers’ purchasing decision process and whether they are satisfied with the Company’s products/services/payment/delivery, etc.
When considering the competition, what do you know about their competitors? Does the Company have defensible barriers to entry? In other words, would it be tough for a competitor to enter the market? What are their key advantages? Can you learn more about the company from other industry participants? Is their intellectual property protected?
Management, Investors, Employees and Related Parties
Have you reviewed their organization chart and biographical information? How complete is it? Are there any concerns relating to employees, key managers or current Investors?
Have you reviewed the audited (or, if unavailable, unaudited) financials, projections, changes in product or service margins, changes in Accounts Receivable or Accounts Payable? Do you know what are the terms of the debt that the Company has on its books – is it able to meet those obligations with its Operating Income? Does the Company have a good relationship with its lenders? What Liens are on the Company’s assets?
Corporate Documents of the Company and Subsidiaries
Check to make sure the Articles of Incorporation / Operating Agreements, corporate bylaws, Board meeting minutes etc. are available to uncover any potential issues.
Previous Financings and Capital Structure
Have there been any previously issued Securities, Convertible debt instruments or other items that may affect the number of shares outstanding and, therefore, your prospective percent ownership in the Company? What does the Capitalization Table look like?
Material Contracts and Agreements
Are there any in place that are of consequence to the Investor?
An Investor should learn about any pending or prior lawsuits involving the Company or the Founders.
The Company should provide a list of real property it owns with titles, deeds of trust, mortgages, etc. It should also provide documents relating to proprietary technology and copyright or patent filings to determine whether the intellectual property is protected.
Are there any issues regarding the Company or the Principals relating to the federal or state tax authorities? The Company should be able to provide evidence that it is current with its taxes.
Insurance and Liability
Does the Company carry insurance policies covering property, liabilities and operations? Are there any other insurance policies in force, such as “key man” policies or director indemnification policies?
Acquisition, Partnership or Joint Venture Agreements
Are there any material agreements in place or documents pertaining to potential acquisitions or alliances?
Governmental Regulations and Filings
Are there any issues relating to government regulations, filings, permits, licenses or other that are material for an Investor to understand?
Are the facility, machinery and equipment in operational order? Has the Company established Key Performance Indicators to manage and improve efficiency?
If an online portal exists, an Investor should look for:
• Company overview: management, backgrounds (criminal or otherwise), liens and judgements, business description, history, etc.
• Corporate documents, e.g. operating agreement, articles of incorporation, certificate of incorporation, organization charts, etc.
• Financial: analysis and supporting files, financial statements, projections, bank statements
• Company operations, business plan, sales and distribution plan
• Description of products and services
• Market overview: Industry metrics and trends
• Competition, barriers to entry, comparative prices
• Previous financings; agreement details, etc.
• Regulatory filings
• Material contracts and agreements with customers and suppliers
Investing in a private Company is highly risky. You should verify as much information as possible to avoid misrepresenting the facts or to detect fraud, both about the investment and the Principals behind the investment.
*A version of this article is originally published on Carofin’s website. Carofin is an alternative investment marketplace. STRATA is a wholly-owned subsidiary of Horizon Bank, SSB, and has no affiliation or ownership with Carofin. In addition, this content is for educational purposes only and should not be viewed as an endorsement by STRATA Trust Company.