Real estate is a popular investment with numerous opportunities. For instance, it could be purchased outright by an individual or through a real estate investment trust (REIT) inside an IRA. When the market was booming in the early 2000s, many investors flipped homes to capitalize on steadily increasing demand and property values. Although the days when real estate seemed like a sure thing may be over, such investments may still be appropriate, especially within an IRA. Done properly, real estate investments can provide significant gains through appreciation and rental income.
Tax Laws Help Real Estate Investors
Usually, those who sell a real estate investment outside an IRA are subject to taxation on any gain. Property held for at least 12 months is subject to the lower long-term capital gains tax instead of regular income tax. But there is an important exception. Internal Revenue Code §1031 eliminates taxation on real estate sales if the property that is sold is replaced with "like-kind" property within 180 days. These "1031 exchanges" have made it much easier for investors to buy and sell real estate without getting taxed on the transactions. But 1031 exchanges can also be tricky, so investors should seek sound advice before pursuing such a transaction.
Because 1031 exchanges can be so beneficial, self-directed IRA (SDIRA) owners often ask whether this special tax treatment can be used within an IRA. The short answer is "no.” However, the good news is that there is no need to, as IRAs already enjoy their own favorable tax treatment.
![]()
Real Estate Investments Inside and Outside of Self-Directed IRAs
Real estate is also a common SDIRA investment. One reason for this is that IRA earnings are tax-deferred (for both Traditional and Roth IRAs) and potentially tax-free (for Roth IRAs only). At the very least, neither kind of IRA is taxed until the owner takes a distribution. All accrued earnings within the IRA increase the account's fair market value, without triggering taxation. When IRA assets are withdrawn, the owner (or beneficiary) will include any taxable amount as ordinary income. This is quite different from assets that are held outside an IRA.
Real estate held outside an IRA
Holding real estate as an investment outside an SDIRA can also provide tax benefits. These assets may be subject to favorable long-term capital gains treatment if they are held for at least 12 months before sale. Understanding the advantages of holding these assets within an SDIRA becomes clearer, however, when you compare them with holding the assets outside an IRA.
Example: April bought a rental property for $300,000 several years ago. She sold it for $400,000 this year. Her 2025 taxable income of approximately $150,000 puts her in a 24% federal tax bracket. For the property sale, however, the long-term capital gains rate for her income level is only 15%. So she will pay $15,000 in tax on the $100,000 gain on the house's value, rather than $24,000. On the other hand, any rental income earned in 2025 is taxed as ordinary income at a rate of 24%.
Real estate held within an IRA
The tax rules for IRAs are usually straightforward. Distributions from Traditional IRAs are subject to taxation as ordinary income to the extent that the assets have not already been taxed (such as when nondeductible contributions are made). Qualified distributions from Roth IRAs are not taxed at all. For nonqualified distributions, only the distributed earnings are taxed; Roth contributions have already been taxed and are not taxed again when distributed.
Example: Assume the same facts as in the example above, except that April bought the property in her self-directed Roth IRA. If this property is sold within the IRA (e.g., for later reinvestment of the proceeds), there is no current tax implication for April. If April takes a distribution after age 59½ and after the Roth IRA has existed for at least 5 taxable years, there is still no tax obligation on this qualified distribution.
These IRA tax rules, which provide for tax-deferred or even tax-free growth, create better long-term savings prospects than do the 1031 exchange rules. While it is true that capital gains rates are lower than ordinary income tax rates, many savers will benefit more from holding their real estate investments within an SDIRA. Of course, some investors may take advantage of both methods: holding some real estate inside an IRA and some outside an IRA. A competent financial professional can advise you on what makes the most sense.
![]()
Is Real Estate Investing for You?
With numerous options for investing your SDIRA assets, real estate may be a worthwhile consideration. Keep in mind, however, that this option may be more complicated than other investment options. For example, real estate held within your SDIRA may require an independent property manager, which will help avoid prohibited transactions. Annual valuations will also be needed to meet IRS reporting requirements. But even with added hurdles to clear, real estate held in an SDIRA may be worth exploring. STRATA's SDIRA experts can help you understand some of these additional requirements. Looking to learn more? Check out our article discussing the Pros and Cons of investing in Real Estate through your self-directed IRA.